Overall I would recommend the triscuit & lippie. They are not really a must have. The triscuit does have more pigment than what can be seen in the online swatches but not much - enough to see a definate light pink vs. taupe on the brush & eye. If you don't have the extra $$ to spend, I would pass on GE & Pink cloud - unless you want a pink highlighter. GE is very nice in texture & application, but the color is not really that unique IMHO. I have seen it elsewhere.
I am loving this collection...
Thanks so much - that's a big help. I'm prone to that "punched in the eye" look too so I share your disappointment.
Haven, you are an NW20, right? I wonder if it might work any better on an NC skintone? It'll be interesting to see what Cafemakeup and/or Sabrina have to say about it if they do reviews since they are both NCs.
Haven, you are an NW20, right? I wonder if it might work any better on an NC skintone? It'll be interesting to see what Cafemakeup and/or Sabrina have to say about it if they do reviews since they are both NCs.
I got it and now prefer it over Prelude. I am NC 30-35 and Chanel VA in B30. I tend to look good in purples and dark blues. For instance, MAC's Contrast looks really good on me.
Haven, how did it go when you gave it another try? Did you see Cafemakeup's review today:
http://cafemakeup.com/2011/08/19/chanel-vanites-swatches-and-review/
I can see where the shade that she calls the "gold duochrome" shade could definitely look bruisey on anyone. I like the looks of the other 3 shades, and I like the gold duochrome shade at certain angles, but interesting how she points out that it applies on the eye as in the pic with her arm tilted -- looks like major bruisey potential there to me. I think that shade would have to be used very sparingly.