Ok, you got me to HAVE to go see & read
She is SOOOOOOO wrong on the lipsticks in SO many ways! If that many products (& we've listed them) lipsticks, powders, blushes are so bad & dry & powdery...the problem just may be her skin. I have not found that to be the case on my lips & skin. Its insane to me that these are given a B- & C! We've tried them & we know they're good & the other beauty reviewers feel the same way. Other than the pencils, I haven't seen another complaint like hers. Everyone I read said they were so creamy & elegant feeling on the lips with great color saturation. Even the sheer I got gave me great color.
This one really gets me: It's ridiculous that she wants them to stand up
That's like saying you don't want the Mona Lisa to look at you with those eyes
Its ART! Its CREATIVE & its OUTSIDE the box & its wonderful. Its Christian Louboutin for heavens sake.
I have nothing against her either & appreciate the swatches...but she is just plain wrong on the CL & we all know it. The grading system is well....