ratmist
Well-known member
Quote:
It just depends on whether someone feels strongly about flags in the first place. A lot of people just don't. Others don't trust a flag to truly and adequately symbolise their thoughts or emotions in a way that isn't going to be misconstrued by someone else. And lastly, in places where a flag can be flown, it is a choice to fly it or not, and people make the judgement call and act accordingly.
Quote:
Respecting a tradition is not the same as taking part in that tradition. It's someone else's tradition - not yours. If you are a 'guest' - as in, not an immigrant seeking permanent domicile - then it could be construed as rude at best or disengenous at worst to take on traditions that you cannot claim as your heritage.
Quote:
Well, if you're an American and you bow to another flag or salute a monarch, you automatically are disrespecting your own nation. Funny how you can't win either way, if you take it from that point of view.
For example, living as an American in Scotland, I personally find it extremely amusing to see Americans coming over and buying/wearing kilts in an attempt to connect with their heritage. Most Scots find it rather amusing or annoying, depending on who you talk to. "Respecting the local tradition" is an awfully ambiguous statement. Some may prefer that you not take part in the local tradition in order to properly respect it. Certainly one should make sure that the locals aren't going to be offended by your behaviour. But you are absolutely wrong to say that as a guest in the UK you should bow to the flag and salute the queen. The average Brit doesn't do either, and would not expect or ask a foreigner to do it in some vain attempt to respect the local culture.
It just depends on whether someone feels strongly about flags in the first place. A lot of people just don't. Others don't trust a flag to truly and adequately symbolise their thoughts or emotions in a way that isn't going to be misconstrued by someone else. And lastly, in places where a flag can be flown, it is a choice to fly it or not, and people make the judgement call and act accordingly.
Quote:
Respecting a tradition is not the same as taking part in that tradition. It's someone else's tradition - not yours. If you are a 'guest' - as in, not an immigrant seeking permanent domicile - then it could be construed as rude at best or disengenous at worst to take on traditions that you cannot claim as your heritage.
Quote:
Well, if you're an American and you bow to another flag or salute a monarch, you automatically are disrespecting your own nation. Funny how you can't win either way, if you take it from that point of view.
For example, living as an American in Scotland, I personally find it extremely amusing to see Americans coming over and buying/wearing kilts in an attempt to connect with their heritage. Most Scots find it rather amusing or annoying, depending on who you talk to. "Respecting the local tradition" is an awfully ambiguous statement. Some may prefer that you not take part in the local tradition in order to properly respect it. Certainly one should make sure that the locals aren't going to be offended by your behaviour. But you are absolutely wrong to say that as a guest in the UK you should bow to the flag and salute the queen. The average Brit doesn't do either, and would not expect or ask a foreigner to do it in some vain attempt to respect the local culture.