Quote:
Originally Posted by reesesilverstar
Again with the hypocrisy and clear ignorance... Is what you're talking about a religious or a social issue? Where is it spelled out that a muslim society should NOT educate it's women and girls, when in the Qur'an men are instructed to choose intelligent, pious and compassionate women to be their wives? Logically, would that make sense? No... Choosing not to educate a society, is that an issue specific to the muslim world? Be honest. No... Look at the history of education in the world. Look at the debate on intelligent design and why it's not taught in schools. Is the "liberty" of masturbation chastised only in Islam? No... Muslims should always dissociate with the fringe and do so publicly. But has the BASTION of catholicism come out and chastise and remove affiliation with priests who molest little boys, CHILDREN??????? NOOOOOOOO!!!
So like I said before, let's be real when we approach an argument. Don't look at just one. Explore the board.
|
I have a very dear friend who's Muslim. The guy is just one of the most intelligent, goodhearted, steadfast people I know.
He and I were talking one time about our faiths, etc., and he very plainly said that one of his biggest criticisms of his faith/culture/upbringing is how it treats women. "Women aren't valued in my culture, they don't really count. We're supposed to take care of you, but what you want or how you feel or what you think about something, it doesn't matter, because we're the men and what we say goes."
That's not my opinion. That's the opinion of a Muslim man...and when a Muslim man tells me something like that, it only reinforces my already negative views of the religion*.
Speaking of the qur'an, what does it have to say about a man disciplining his wife? About the measures he can take to be the head of his household? What does it say about the man and his role as the spiritual and physical leader of his household? What does the qur'an have to say about how women are to be treated
once a woman has done something that can be interpreted as against the holy word or disrespectful to her husband?
Sure, it's easy to say "Oh, well it says that women are to be chosen for being pious and holy and intelligent", but who determines how pious a woman is, and what her punishment for not being pious enough is?
Quote:
The foster mother struck off for allowing a Muslim girl to convert to Christianity took the child in after she was threatened with an arranged marriage.
The woman, a devout Christian, was asked to care for the teenager after the authorities learned of her abusive family background.
Her father beat her just for chatting to boys and warned he would haul her off to Pakistan to marry against her will, a friend claimed.
But council officials were angered when the girl chose to be baptised. They insist the foster mother failed in her duty to preserve the girl's original religion.
As a result, the girl was removed and the foster mother struck off the register last November, despite having worked with children for ten years with a perfect record.
Neither the carer, who has looked after more than 80 children, nor the girl, who is now 17, can be identified.
But a friend of the girl claimed yesterday:
'Her dad is a very strict Muslim who could get violent. One time he hit her with a belt just because she chatted with a couple of boys.
'Another time he beat her over and over and said he would take her to Pakistan and make her marry.
'She really didn't want that. She was very frightened. Her dad would shout and swear at her and told her that she'd shamed the family.
'Her mother didn't really do anything to protect her.'
After the local authority became aware of the situation the girl was removed from her family and placed with the carer, a single mother of two.
The foster mother says she initially tried to discourage the girl from attending church and offered to take her to a mosque instead.
But the girl, who was 16 at the time, was determined to go to church and after two months chose to be baptised.
The woman said it had never occurred to her that she would be taken off from the register.
The move has stripped her of her sole income and she has had to move into a one-bedroom flat.
Her lawyer Nigel Priestley said the local authority has agreed to review the case next month.
It is the start of a process which could lead to her being reinstated as a foster parent.
Mike Judge, from the Christian Institute, which is funding her case, said: 'In any free society people must be free to change their religion.'
The case follows the controversy over Caroline Petrie, 45, the Christian nurse in Somerset suspended without pay in December for offering to pray for an elderly female patient. |
Muslim girl in baptism row was fleeing an arranged marriage | Mail Online
Quote:
However, “the veil” for Muslim women may be the most misunderstood of all and may make Muslim women look oppressed in the eyes of non-Muslims. However, after earnestly studying Al-Quran and Hadith (Islamic Holy Scripture and the Prophet’s practices) 11 years ago, I myself started wearing the veil because I totally agreed that the particular Islamic rule is truly for a woman’s own safety and protection of her mind and body. |
?The Contemporary Muslim Woman” Series: Oppressed! GOATMILK: An intellectual playground edited by Wajahat Ali
Yes. It's definitely a woman's job to cover her head and face completely so that she may not be the temptress that leads a man down the path of sin. It's DEFINITELY not on the man's shoulders to control his urges. Obviously, him giving in to sexual thoughts is HER fault, not his own lack of self control.
There's a portion of Gone With The Wind where Scarlett and Rhett are talking about life after Frank Kennedy and Scarlett's widow status, and Rhett expresses his disgust at how American society treated its widows. Scarlett holds to the morals, and is shocked at his cavalier attitude. Rhett responds with "How tightly women cling to the chains that bind them!"
Reading these threads I have much the same thought.
*Islam isn't the only religion I'm critical of. I'm critical of most religions and their practices, but I'm not singling Islam out on its own. I'm also critical of ANY fundamentalist religion, the mormon church, and that quiverfull crap.