I have the brown HIP creme liner.
It's so much easier to apply than my Liquidlast, but the color is slightly lighter than Cocobar. It's pretty longwearing and it didn't smudge or transfer, but it didn't entirely stand up to the "I have allergies and work on a computer and occasionally forget not to rub my eyes like gangbusters" test --- it flaked off a teeny bit.
Overall I was impressed. Liquidlast is more durable, but Liquidlast is so tricky to apply that I can't use it in the morning --- HIP, I could.