MAC By Request discussion
- Thread starter LMD84
- Start date
Copperhead
Well-known member
Moxie and Rocker while pretty, probably aren't even the same as their originals as well.
Dreaming Dancer
Well-known member
I think batches might just vary some because i have worn Viva Glam V for years and go thru tubes like crazy, and there have been times i have gotten some that are a tad more beige and then when i re-buy it again, it is more pink again. i prefer the more pink, but i bet that is all it is. I would think it would be hard to get each batch exact.
Richelle83
Well-known member
Rocker, Party Parrot, Moxie, Old CYY, New CYY, Pink Pigeon
Copperhead
Well-known member
LOL! You're welcome.DOH! Thank you Copperhead. I should have known that.
MACerette
Well-known member
On the other hand... I got one Runaway Red (still from MAC me Over I guess) and one from S3. After all I heard I was really worried I would be let down by the colour differences, but TBH, apart from the appearance of the colour in the tube, the colour looked about the same applied on me.
Copperhead
Well-known member
Your Party Parrot looks to have a good bit of coral in it. I'm wearing PP right now and don't see any coral on my lips. Thanks much for the swatches. How many swipes did you do for each shade?Rocker, Party Parrot, Moxie, Old CYY, New CYY, Pink Pigeon
MACerette
Well-known member
Thanks for the swatches Richelle! Looks lovely!Rocker, Party Parrot, Moxie, Old CYY, New CYY, Pink Pigeon
Have they sold out already? It's been 30 mins or so . I'm looking at the CA site and it says sold out. Any Canadians notice if things were restocked?
OctoberViolet
Well-known member
Oh snap! The newer one reminds me of Pink Pigeon maybe? It's darker not as neon. I wonder why? Maybe customers were complaining about how neon bright CYY was the first time? That was the allure of it...besides the really cute name. Which is why I bought it. LOL.
Old CYY vs New CYY
Jenrbelt
Well-known member
Party Parrot just made my list thanks to your swatches! :eyelove: Unless it is too close to VV Nicki...Rocker, Party Parrot, Moxie, Old CYY, New CYY, Pink Pigeon
valkolak
Well-known member
Maybe we're all going to have to go buy the Stila dupe for CYY. MAC, you do this to yourself!
Richelle83
Well-known member
Usually 2 swipes.
Dreaming Dancer
Well-known member
still shows add to bag for me and lets me add it to bag. I am in USA, so i don't know about CA.
honey on boost
Well-known member
They are still available on the US site.
OctoberViolet
Well-known member
Thank you, Richelle! I still love my Party Parrot. CYY & Pink Pigeon aren't too great on me, but I still love them. Rocker & Moxie are to die for. I can't wait to get them. Fingers crossed tomorrow or Friday.
Rocker, Party Parrot, Moxie, Old CYY, New CYY, Pink Pigeon
valkolak
Well-known member
Thanks for comparing! So new CYY isn't like PP but it's still pretty. Maybe it'll be more fall appropriate than the original.Rocker, Party Parrot, Moxie, Old CYY, New CYY, Pink Pigeon
new formula actually might work with my skin tone better
Old CYY vs New CYY
Babylard
Well-known member
Canadians aren't allowed to purchase from the US Site. :/ It seems most of the lipsticks went to the US xD
