I went to a PRO store earlier this week and had planned on getting Aqua in the pan. When I swatched it, it reminded me a lot of Haunting (from Alexander McQueen). Although I can't say objectively how they compare since I didn't have Haunting on me, it seemed similar enough to prevent me from getting it. Plus, I've only worn Haunting, like, once since I got it, and it's been a while since that collection came out.
I went to the nearby freestanding store today to check out the collection, having planned to get Sassy Grass and Crazy Cool.
- Sassy Grass is probably as close to what you're going to imagine when you say "matte green" as you can get. The color is a bright, vivid grass green. I thought it would be similar to Kelly (PRO), but it's not even close. The texture is not perfect, but it's not bad.
- Crazy Cool is lighter than Beautiful Iris and darker than Digit. I wouldn't say that Crazy Cool is a dupe for Beautiful Iris. They have a completely different look because of the purple duochrome that Beautiful Iris has. If you are just considering shade, however, they are pretty similar, and in a look they probably won't look so distinctly different to necessarily warrant purchasing both (unless you're hardcore). I don't have Beautiful Iris, and I ended up picking up Crazy Cool because I wanted a lighter lavender and it has a softer texture.
- Louder, Please was not even on my "maybe" list because it is such a bold color. I swatched it out of curiosity, though, and... that was a big mistake for my wallet. The texture was SO perfect, so smooth... And it was very pigmented, without the blotchyness that comes with a lot of matte colors. Even though I KNEW I wouldn't wear this nearly enough to justify the money I would be paying for it, I ended up getting it, determined to incorporate it somewhere, somehow (confessions of a MACaholic -_-).