I really couldn't handle getting through all the posts in this thread in the past few days, so I'll just ask this here and leave it at that:
Dodgy Girl and KYY = gorgeous for many reasons, but oh my god, they left an unmanageable stain when I tested them out. For me, it was worse than a stain, and almost like an allergic reaction, that I couldn't tell if it was due to something in the lipsticks or just something related to my efforts to get that stain out with every product I had on hand. Anyone else with this issue?
I'm still going to get them both, because for me, they're MAC's best in breed of these colors (yet, lol), but I feel like I am going to have to majorly shield my lips with Prep & Prime, lip pencil and god knows what else, once I pick them up in-store. Dodgy Girl, in particular, also had rather poor staying quality, in that it changed color on me in about an hour, I think due to whatever the hell was going on with my lips underneath, and lost some of its beautiful, glowing vibrancy. I expect I will have to re-apply frequently when I wear it all day or all evening.