i still have my one tub of original packaged volcanic ash exfoliater. i love it. my friends do not like the smell of it, but i think the scent is lovely and clean. i apply it on dry skin, scrub, add a little water to my fingertips, scrub some more until all the sugar scrub crystals are melted. i use it once a week or once every other week and the tub is still nearly full from, what 2 years ago now? anyway i'll be repurchasing that, even though i'm disappointed to see the amount of product went down.
even though i too hate limited edition skin stuff to fall in love with, i'm going to try the volcanic ash mask too. i figure it is something i'll just use infrequently so it should at least last a while (until the next new thing comes along!).
so for the makeup: i plan on getting baby goth girl nail lacquer, gilt by association mes. young punk and cinderfella will be put away as Christmas gifts for my daughter.
oh and i just bought the greasepaint stick on ebay (was overcome by uncontrollable need to buy something tonight)...so if i like it, will purchase a couple more of those.
and as always, thank you to all that post pictures and dish about the good bad ugly of each collection