I played with the testers today at Nordstrom during my lunch break. Here are the products that I liked:
1. I think Cuddle is my favorite, then Nurture and Warm&Cozy. Someone else mentioned that the sticks are creamier. They are and I am so glad. I used to hate shadesticks because they were so hard to apply. These ones are definitely easier to blend and work with.
2. Lipstick in Warm Me Up. This is a really great neutral pink. I love Amplified anyway. Spiced Tea was nice too. I wasn't sure about Siss. It looked great on the MA with 3N on top but I couldn't see myself using it often.
3. Lipglass in Light that Fire. Loved the coral color! I also liked 2N and 3N since I skipped on the N collection.
4. The only eyeshadow that caught my eye was Chamomile and the texture was nice. I know it sounds cheesy but since I like Chamomile, I am getting it. Does it make sense? Nope.
5. MSF in By Candlelight is a great highlighter. I didn't like Comfort at all. For some reason, it turned out orangy on my skin. It wouldn't even work as a bronzer for me. Karla Sugar's swatch is accurate and I am NC30.
6. I liked the dark brown nail polish but still not impressed with MAC's quality. The texture has improved but OPI or Zoya probably has a similar color and they are cheaper.
Here is my list:
3x shadesticks (Cuddle, Nurture, Warm&Cozy)
2x lipsticks (Spiced Tea, Warm Me Up)
3x lipglasses (Light That Fire!, 2N, 3N)
1x MSF (By Candlelight)
1x eye shadow (Chamomile)
Hope this helps. Happy Shopping!