Plushlash mascara - yay or nay?

[thewickedstyle]

I just got mine and am test driving at work today. I put on one coat for a day look, no curler. I really want to see how it lasts and wears.

It really lengthened; I didn't build huge volume since it's for work, I'll play with it more tonight.

One coat:

Sorry for the scary eyeball pic

 

[Danapotter]

This is my HG mascara. It defines and lengthens. It does not clump and you can make your lashes get different looks depending on what side you use. This is MAC's best mascara!

 

[bebs]

how does this compare to dior show.. does anybody know.. I love them but I'm tired of shelling out over $20 ever two months and would love it if I could stop.. however I'm addicted to the results

(could somebody tell me that used to use dior?) thank you!

 

[Lipglass*Lover*]

*~*After reading this thread I really want to get some of this...NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!! I can't wait to try it!!!*~*

 

[silverbelle282]

Re: Pplushlash mascara - yay or nay?

Quote:

Originally Posted by allan_willb this will cost you, lol jk well let me ask you, was there tester wands in the displayer at the counter? because if you didnt use the correct tester wand then everything u did was incorrect. you first wanna make sure you test the product with the correct wand if not the 2 step swiper system will not work. you first wanna use the flat v-ish side of the brush to apply the mascara with. then the 2nd step is to use the fat round side to lift and brush the lashes.building up the volume.

thank you! no one told me about this! i bought it, i love it. i'm going upstairs to play with it now.

 

[elegant-one]

yay! Received the Plus Lash last week - Love it! I usually only use Dior Show Waterproof, but the Plush Lash is a great every day mascara. It creates soft, defined, and lengthened lashes and it never smeared or smudged in hot weather all day. Not as vavoom as Dior, but it is a great mascara. Great price too.

 

[thanh13]

I've never been a fan of MAC mascara, but I have to admit that this one is really tempting me.

 

[elegant-one]

I've tried every mascara under the sun and they all clump to some degree...the Plush Lash really lives up to the no clumping. It separates the lashes and defines them beautifully.

 

[Babycakes]

i still prefer zoom lash..this one didn't do much but I prob.didn't use it right though..

 

[mzmiztiza]

I was actually surprised that this mascara gave me some volume. I didn't know about the 2 step wiping method until I read the boards. But now that I look at the brush I can totally see the flat vs. round side. I'd actually recommend buying it and trying it out!

 

[chazza]

is it waterproof and smudge-proof?

 

[mena22787]

can anyone post some pics of before and after w/ this mascara? tia!

 

[elegant-one]

The MAC description says "no clumping, spiking, smudging or flaking." It doesn't say waterproof.

I wore it all day in high heat and it absolutely did not smudge, smear, or have any flaky residue under or around my eyes. It looked the same at the end of the day as it did when I first applied it.

 

[Angelah]

The 2 step swiping system issss correct. I mean, you don't really have to do it that way.. but to get the full effect of the mascara... that's definately what you want to do.

I tell everyone who is addicted to Zoomlast to try this mascara out.. because it's pretty much Zoom, but better. I love that Plush is a jelly consistancy because when it dries, it doesn't dry to a powdery finish on your lashes.. it stays fairly moist so you won't get the flakes of mascara under your eyes by the end of the night.

 

[oddinary]

Will it hold a curl? My curl is incredibly weak, so most non WP mascaras weigh it down.

 

[AlliSwan]

Before and after pictures...sorry they aren't the best (and sorry I look a bit crazed, I was trying to open my eyes really wide for the pics haha), and they don't even show the mascara's true potential as this was done in 3 minutes before work, but so you can get an idea:

Before

After one coat

After two coats

 

[ShexyKristin]

I saw it yesterday when I got some new eyeshadows but I didn't try it. I just got new mascara from Lancome so I didn't bother. But after hearing all this good stuff I want to go out and get some!

 

[kimmy]

i just got brownette...i think it smells good. but it doesn't seem to me like it's a whole lot better than any other mascara. i saw some before and afters and on most people it makes a huge difference but the mac lady said that since my eyelashes are already long, that probably explains why it doesn't really impress me as much as i thought it would...idk though, i'm gonna keep using it and maybe after a few tries it'll win me over!

 

[Stormy]

I just got plushlash on line, and I'm not 100% impressed. It looks good in the beginning but flakes off during the day and smudges underneath my eyes, and I am only applying it to my top lashes. I'll stick with my Dior Show.

 

[DOLLface]

My mom actually bought this yesterday when she was at our local counter. She tried it today and wasn't that impressed with it, so I tried it this afternoon and was surprised at the result. I had been interested in this mascara before the release and I had just seen it on the website, but since I haven't always heard the best things about MAC mascaras I was a bit nervous about how it would turn out. To my surprise it was quite nice, not as much volume as I would have liked, but I was still happy with the result. I didn't read about the 2-step system until after, while I was reading a few beauty blogs, so I will definately give it another try tomorrow. It is also a cheaper alternative to my BadGal Lash, so I'll probably pick up a tube of it for when I run out and maybe don't have enough to pick up a new tube.