I used to go for dior.. my MA that I love and trust told me to try it and if I didnt like it just take it back no foul no loss if I didnt like it and this was about 2 weeks ago, and now I use it every day!
I put eyedrops in every few hours because I had eye surgery, it didnt smudge to much or anything like that, this stuff stands up to my day and makes me throw out the dior show and save a little bit of money.. and instead buy a brown and a black one at the same time!
I would say at least try it you have nothing to lose because if you dont fall inlove just keep your recept and return it.. because if I can love it and trade mine in I'm sure you can as well