I just got this recently, and I have to say that I was pleasantly surprised. It lengthens my wimpy lashes like no other, but it doesn't hold a curl very well. I've also used diorshow, and that doesn't lengthen as much as plushlash, but they are both pretty good mascaras! try both and see which one works better for you. Shu Uemura precise volume is a top contender too..it gives me super long, wispy and thick lashes..and it's waterproof! ahh there's just too many to try.