I don't really wear neutral eyes much, to be honest, I tend to just wear liquid liner over a base (usually quarry) in the day.
Fave night looks include:
Goldmine/honey lust in the inner corners/tear ducts.
Tempting all over lid, blended out.
Humid in the crease and under eye, blended.
Plumage over humid under eye and in the outer edge of the crease, blended up.
Goldmine/honey lust in the inner corners/tear ducts.
Tempting all over lid, blended out.
Grape, or my fave YSL purple in the crease and under eye, blended.
Beauty marked over grape under eye and in the outer edge of the crease, blended up.
I should prob experiment a bit more now that I have more mac colours. I only had a few for a long, long time so I got into a routine with the looks/combinations I liked.