Yeah, a thread like this is bound to cause some tension, but if you like the way you look than don't worry about it.
I do alot of the things that people have mentioned on here (bright eyeshadow, glitter, black liner all around my eyes) and not a day goes by that I don't get complimented on my makeup...especially by guys so maybe I just blend it well, who knows?
Either way...these are just personal opinions and not meant to hurt anyone's feelings. I'm sure for every crazy makeup trend that can look awful on most people, there is atleast someone somewhere who can pull it off amazingly.
I personally look awful with eyeliner in my waterline, but for most people it looks great yet I'm told everytime I wear neon green eyeshadow that it looks amazing yet most people say they couldn't wear it so whatever it is...it just depends on who you are whether it looks good or not.
Now the tadpole eyebrows may be an exception........