Quote:
Originally Posted by Beauty Mark
I'll try one last time
If you say you're good, you are saying that you're well-behaved. LIke if you say, "What a good kid!" you're commenting on behavior vs. state of being.
If you say you're well, you are doing fine (emotionally/physically). Normally, when someone asks how you are, they're more interested in how you're physically/emotionally doing than if you're an upright citizen
|
I'll add a bit more here, if I may, to make this good/well thing as clear as mud on every level of the argument.
Grammatically, "good" is either a noun or an adjective (a modifier of a noun), while "well" is either an adjective or an adverb (which modifies a verb/action). Saying something like "shoes are good" is correct, because "good," used here to mean desirable, directly modifies "shoes" via a linking verb, "to be" (conjugated here as "are"). However, if you like how the shoes
fit, you would say, "the shoes fit well." "Well" modifies the verb "fit," not the shoes themselves. Saying "the shoes fit good" makes no sense because "good," as an adjective, cannot modify a verb/action (cannot modify the verb "fit").
The biggest problem with saying something like "I am doing good" is that the only way "good" makes sense in this sentence is as a noun, because it cannot modify the verb "doing" as an adjective. If you tell someone that you are "doing good," you are telling them that you are doing something beneficial for society like curing cancer or feeding the homeless (which are "goods" performed for the common welfare), because "good" can only be a noun here. It is not modifying the noun "I," so when you say "I am doing good," you think that you are modifying "I," but you are not. You are techically using it as a noun, saying you are doing
something.
You say you are "doing well" because "well" is an adverb and can modify the verb "doing," thus "well" describes the quality of the "doing" or "feeling," or whichever similar verb you use. You can also say "I am well," because "well" can also be an adjective, modifying "I" via the linking verb "am," much like "good" modified the shoes above.
The point that Beauty Mark is making about saying "I am good" is more a question of the meaning of "good" itself. "Good" in this sense is, in fact, grammatically correct, as it is doing its job as an adjective and modifing "I" via the linking verb "am." However, it's the definition of "good" that is the problem. "Good" as an adjective to modify a person usually refers to them being morally upright, well-behaved, or benevolent, so if you say that you are good, you are technically saying that you are a "good person," not that you feel fine. "Well" is a description of health, which is what someone is inquiring after, essentially, when they are asking you how you are doing. They don't generally want to know if you are benevolent when they ask you that.
I hope that helped
someone.